All posts
analyticsplanning

Which Shows Should You Repeat Next Year? A Post-Show Scorecard

Why You Need a Scorecard

By the end of the season, most vendors have a rough feeling about each show. This one was great. That one was a slog. The one with the nice organizer was probably fine. The trouble is that feelings are a bad way to plan a calendar. Memory favors the last show you did, the one with the best story, or the one that was most fun. None of those are the same as the one that paid best.

A scorecard fixes that. It's a short, consistent set of questions you answer for every show, ideally right after it ends. When applications open for next year, you don't have to remember. You look at the scores and the decisions mostly make themselves.

It doesn't need to be complicated. Four areas cover almost everything: net profit, income per hour, effort, and crowd fit.

1. Net Profit

Start with the money, and start with net, not gross. A show that brought in a lot of sales can still be a poor show once you take out the booth fee, travel, lodging, food, help and card fees. A smaller show with low costs can quietly beat it.

  • Total sales. Everything you took in, across every payment method.
  • Total costs. Booth fee, mileage, hotel, meals, crew pay, card fees, and anything else you spent to be there.
  • Net. Sales minus costs. This is the number that matters.

If you didn't break even, that's important information too. A break-even calculator can tell you how much you'd need to sell next time to cover the costs, which helps you decide whether a better spot or a different product mix might fix it, or whether the show just isn't a fit.

2. Income Per Hour

Net tells you how much you made. Income per hour tells you how well you used your time. It's your net profit divided by the hours you spent on the show. Count setup, breakdown and drive time too if you want the honest version.

This is the number that settles arguments between shows of different lengths. A three-day festival might have the biggest net of your year, but if it took forty hours of your life, it might be worse per hour than a four-hour evening market down the road. Income per hour puts them on the same scale.

If you track your shows in FairKeep, it works out income per hour for you, and you can choose in Settings whether to count setup and breakdown time. That makes it easy to line up every show from the season and see which ones were truly worth your time.

3. Effort

Some costs don't show up in the numbers. A show can be profitable and still be one you dread. Score the effort honestly, because effort is what burns you out by December.

  • Travel. How far, how long, and how stressful was the drive?
  • Load-in and load-out. Was it a smooth drive-up, or a long haul across a parking lot with a hand cart?
  • Setup. Did the space, the rules or the timing make setup harder than usual?
  • Organization. Did the organizer communicate clearly, keep to schedule, and handle problems well?
  • Conditions. Weather, heat, cold, wind, indoor lighting and noise all count.

A simple one-to-five score for effort is enough. The point is to catch the shows that are fine on paper but cost you more energy than they're worth.

4. Crowd Fit

The last area is whether the people who came were your people. A busy show with the wrong crowd can be worse than a quiet show with the right one.

  • Were shoppers looking for handmade work, or for bargains?
  • Did they buy at your price points, or did they browse and leave?
  • Did the products you're best known for sell, or only your cheapest items?
  • Did people sign up for your list, follow you, or ask where else you'll be?

Crowd fit is often the best predictor of whether a show will improve over time. A show with the right crowd and a weak first year might be worth a second try with a better spot. A show with the wrong crowd rarely gets better.

A Sample Scorecard

Here is a simple version you can copy. One line per show, filled in the day after:

  • Net profit: the dollar figure after every cost.
  • Income per hour: net divided by your total hours, setup and drive included.
  • Effort, one to five: where one is easy and five is exhausting.
  • Crowd fit, one to five: where five means the shoppers were exactly your buyers.
  • One change: the single thing you would do differently next time.

The "one change" line is the part most vendors skip and the part that turns a so-so show into a better one. If you can name a specific fix, like a different spot, more small items, or a canopy weight upgrade, the show belongs in your Fix group, not your Drop group.

Write It Down While It's Fresh

The scorecard only works if you fill it in. The best time is the evening after the show or the next morning, before the details blur. It takes five minutes: your net, your hours, an effort score, a crowd score, and a few lines of notes about what you'd change.

Keep the notes specific. "Booth near the entrance, sold out of small prints by two, cold wind all afternoon, organizer great" is far more useful next year than "pretty good." If you use FairKeep, the Event Diary keeps those notes with the show, and because entries are filed under the event's name, next year's run of the same show opens with this year's notes already there.

Turning Scores Into Decisions

When application season comes back around, lay out every show you did with its scores. You'll usually find they fall into a few groups.

  • Keep. Strong net, strong income per hour, reasonable effort, good crowd. Book these first and build the rest of your calendar around them.
  • Fix. Good crowd and potential, but something held them back: a bad spot, the wrong stock, bad weather. Try once more with a specific change in mind.
  • Swap. Middling numbers and middling crowd. Look for a better show on the same weekend. Search your area on FairFinder for alternatives before you default to a repeat.
  • Drop. Low net, low income per hour, high effort or the wrong crowd. Let these go. Your time is worth more at a better show or at home making stock.

Be willing to drop shows you like. Some of the hardest calls are the friendly little markets that never quite pay. If you keep one for reasons other than money, that's fine, but make it a choice and not a habit.

Look Across More Than One Year

One season is a snapshot. Two or three are a trend. If you keep using the same scorecard, you'll start to see which shows are steady, which are growing, and which are slowly fading. That's when the scorecard really pays off, because you stop reacting to one good or bad day and start planning around what each show reliably does for you.

A good calendar isn't built by booking everything you did last year. It's built by keeping the shows that earn their spot, fixing the ones that could, and making room for better ones. A five-minute scorecard after every show is all it takes.